International Perspective

There has always been a delicate cross when it comes to patent and software innovations. Over the years, there has been diverse approaches to meeting the same on a universal level. Different countries at whole levels have taken divergent positions as to how appealing patentability of software innovation should be. The US has in the past afforded more pervasiveness for patent protection to be enjoyed for software compared to other European countries that have been considered much more restrictive in this regard.

Software patents have been awarded in the United States for decades with much innovation but also patent litigation. However, with time, the requirements to be patent eligible evolved through the court decisions that made patents hard to obtain for some types of software.

Internationally, there are agreements that set minimum standards on intellectual property protection. The Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights previously included patents and others. However, the application of standards is different in each country due to their interpretation and practices.

And now technology does not just bring change but also fresh faces, whereas innovation may pose different but changing questions and controversies on ethics and even equitability in patent ideas for such software products, similarly AI and machine learning.

The relationship between patents and software innovations is uncertain and in constant evolution in a global setting. Countries must also tread this sensitive balance between patent protection as an incentive for innovation and the danger of overly broad patents that might stifle competition or creativity in the software industry. It is a landscape constantly changing with new technologies emerging and the legal frameworks being developed to challenge them.

GROWING TECHNOLOGIES: METAVERSE AND VIRTUAL REALITY

Technologies such as the metaverse and virtual reality are transformative at a huge level but somehow have changed or we can alter the way we interact digitally.

A collective, assimilated virtual space has been developed through the combination of physical reality and virtual reality known as the metaverse. It is a space wherein users can interact with a computer-generated environment and interact in real-time with other users. Companies such as Meta, once known as Facebook, perceive the metaverse as the future internet, where people will come to work, socialize, and have fun.

[Image Sources: Shutterstock]

VR is the short term for virtual reality. Computer technology is used to simulate the world. Users immersed in this artificial world usually achieve this by wearing their headsets, and generally interacting with it by specialized controllers. VR has its use in a variety of areas such as gaming, education, healthcare, training simulation, among others.

VR is an integral part of the metaverse experience, providing users with immersive interactions and a sense of presence in the virtual world. As the metaverse continues to evolve, the VR technologies are likely to become more integrated, with more social and collaborative experiences.

LEGAL CHALLENGES IN PATENTING SOFTWARE INNOVATIONS

Software innovations are one of the most difficult things to be patented due to the uniqueness of software and the ever-changing intellectual property law landscape. Some of the key legal challenges in patenting software innovations:

PATENT ELIGIBILITY AND SUBJECT MATTER

In many jurisdictions, including the United States, there are ongoing challenges about what exactly constitutes patent-eligible subject matter for software. Courts and the patent office often struggle with questions of whether a software invention is abstract and, therefore, ineligible for patent protection.

Prior Art and Obviousness: Some of the legal issues in software innovations involve proving that a software invention is novel and thus not obvious to patent it. With times and technology constantly in change and in such fast moving field, however we are able to identify prior art that applies to us and thus it may become hard to establish that a software innovation is non-obvious.

RAPID TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGES

The pace of change in the continually expanding software industry is hard to adapt to with the patent system. Sometimes, by the time the patent is issued, the environment of technology would have changed in such a manner that the invention patented is less relevant or old.

PATENT LAWS AROUND THE WORLD

Patent laws vary in each country. International patenting of software inventions can prove to be very complex. Each jurisdiction differs in its approach toward patent eligibility and uses different standards while assessing patents for software.

ISSUES OF OPEN SOURCE AND LICENSING

The problem with patenting also comes from open source software and licensing agreements. Developers can use open source licenses that also prevent patenting their innovations, and crossover between patent law and open source is very difficult.

These require delicate insight when it comes to the technological and legal aspects of software innovation to navigate these legal challenges. Inventors, companies, and legal professionals within the software industry will need to keep abreast of the changing legal landscape and their approach to software patenting should be crafted with care.

UNDERSTANDING METAVERSE, VIRTUAL REALITY, AND SOFTWARE INNOVATION

Definition and Characteristics of Metaverse

A multuser, post-reality virtual, eternal environment which involves both virtual digital and real life.

Its basis lies in the convergence of technologies such as virtual reality and augmented reality, which will enable many interactions between digital objects, people, and virtual environments. As such, the Metaverse would then become a persistent multiuser platform that links to other networks of socially engaging settings. This facility enables dynamic interactions with digital artefacts and smooth real-time embodied user communication. Its early form may even teleport an avatar between a network of virtual worlds. Modern Metaverse integrates social, immersive VR systems, open game worlds working, AR collaboration spaces, and massively multiplayer online video games. The "metaverse" is a virtual and physical reality combined to give a shared online world where users can interact with each other as well as digital objects. Its characteristic features include multi-platform access, decentralization, persistence, interactivity, user-generated content, economics, and commerce, digital avatars, combining AR and VR, social and entertainment functions, and immersive experiences.

The term "metaverse" refers to a set of connected virtual worlds rather than an application or a platform. The content is persistent in that it exists and is dynamically changed whether users are engaged with the application or not, and they are not online. Users may socially interact, collaborate, play games, or any other activity that will eventually result in forming interactions with other users and with their surrounding. Users can create and customize digital content, such as virtual properties, clothing, buildings, or even entire virtual worlds. Many virtual settings in the Metaverse have virtual currencies and economies that allow users to trade, buy, and sell virtual products and services. This will allow users to move around and interact with one another in the metaverse. Because the metaverse is hoped to be available across a variety of different platforms and devices, cross-platform compatibility is an absolute necessity. In some metaverse projects, some attempt a decentralized framework wherein ownership and management of infrastructure and assets are shared across users. The metaverse is always developing with kinds of investments from businesses, such as Meta. In the coming years, the term "metaverse" is more likely to be in importance because the term continues evolving within the digital world.

Author :  Kaustubh Kumar, in case of any query, contact us at Global Patent Filing or write back us via email at support@globalpatentfiling.com.

References

Patent protection for software-implemented inventions (no date) WIPO. Available at: https://www.wipo.int/wipo_magazine/en/2017/01/article_0002.html (Accessed: 11 November 2023).

Tucci, L. (2023) What is the metaverse? an explanation and in-depth guide, WhatIs.com. Available at: https://www.techtarget.com/whatis/feature/The-metaverse-explained-Everything-you-need-to-know (Accessed: 11 November 2023).

Council, B. (2023) Metaverse vs. virtual reality: A detailed comparison, Blockchain Council. Available at: https://www.blockchain-council.org/metaverse/metaverse-vs-virtual-reality/ (Accessed: 10 November 2023).

ibid.

Kempf, B. (2023) Emerging challenges of software & patents , IamIP. Available at: https://iamip.com/emerging-challenges-of-software-patents/#:~:text=One%20thing%20that%20makes%20the,innovation%20should%20enjoy%20copyright%20protection. (Accessed: 10 November 2023).

Mystakidis, S., 2022. Metaverse. Encyclopedia, 2(1), pp.486-497. https://www.mdpi.com/2673-8392/2/1/31

Bahirat, T. (2022) What is metaverse? - everything you need to know, Great Learning Blog: Free Resources what Matters to shape your Career! Available at: https://www.mygreatlearning.com/blog/what-is-metaverse/